More reflections in natural history is a collection of 31 essays by the harvard university paleontologist stephen jay gould. The panda s thumb will introduce a new generation of readers to this unique writer, who has taken the art. Goulds opinions, he provides good arguments and interesting facts. The panda thumbs its nose at the dysteleological arguments of the atheist stephen jay gould john woodmorappe the pandas odd forelimb arrangement has an enlarged wristbone digit commonly called the pandas thumb. Many famous evolutionists like stephen jay gould have popularized an argument that the pandas thumb is poorly designed and thereby could not have. Another example of an allegedly poor design is the pandas thumb. Before a giant panda eats a piece of bambooits favorite mealit grabs the shoot between its flexible thumb and finger and strips off the leaves. A must read for anyone with a keen interest in evolutionary biology. It deals with the common misconception of the day that gender plays any great role in intelligence. The panda thumbs its nose at the arguments of the atheist. Pandas give thumbsup to theory of evolution telegraph.
Gould suggests that this adaptation provides a strong argument against the intelligent design thesis. The panda s thumb 19 2 senseless signs of history 27 3 double trouble 35 2 j. In the pandas thumb, a book of essays, gould explained that the socalled thumb that allows the panda to strip the leaves off bamboo is really. The pandas thumb peated development of very similar adaptations in different lineages as an argument against the central darwinian no tion that evolution. The pandas thumb more reflections in natural history. Panda and dysteleological arguments of stephen jay gould. Stephen jay gould is a serious and gifted interpreter of biological theory, of the history of ideas and of the cultural context of scientific discovery. Its a classic example of gould s skill at making a provocative argument about evolution with a flair so elegant that it could draw in the least scientific reader.
And to gould, the thumb of the giant panda was the epitome of a funny. More reflections in natural history with a touch of humor, geology, evolutionary theory, biology, cartoon characters and even some references to baseball, the pandas thumb definitely makes excellent reading for people with all types of interests. The panda s thumb argument is entirely philosophical, and isnt even consistent. Stephen jay gould pointed this out in his book the pandas thumb, where he cited the apparent suboptimal design of a bony extrusion pandas have for a thumb. Gould says that if god had created the panda, he would have given it a better thumb for eating bamboo. Though gould is not a theist, pandas thumb is not an argument against god, but for the appropriate use of science to describe the natural world. Brocas argument because he had easier access to data on womens brains. More reflections in natural history by stephen jay gould, w. He argued that evolutionary biologists must always remember that a. Is the pandas thumb a clumsy adaptation that refutes. Stephen jay gould on intelligence tests iq, the nature nurture controversy 1995 duration.
Few heroes lower their sights in the prime of their lives. September 10, 1941 may 20, 2002 was an american paleontologist, evolutionary biologist, and historian of science. If not, they at least force the evolutionist to use his limited evolution argument in a manner that is not selfconsistent with the world of nature. So, in my opinion, judge scheindlin will promptly dismiss your suit. The pandas thumb stephen jay gould essay 723 words 3 pages the pandas thumb. Recurring themes of the essays are evolution and its teaching, science biography, probabilities and common sense. Assuming, for sake of argument, that she does not, your suit faces several insurmountable evidentiary obstacles. Publication date 1980 topics evolution biology, natural selection publisher.
Half a wing, half an eye, and byanalogy half a fish lure would not seem to offer any selective advantage for natural selection to work on. The panda s thumb is the second volume in a series of essay collections culled primarily from gould s column this view of life that was published for nearly thirty years in natural history magazine, the official popular journal of the american museum of natural history. Our textbooks like to illustrate evolution with examples of optimal designnearly perfect mimicry of a dead leaf by a butterfly or of a poisonous species by a tasty relative. This argument also assumes that the designer would want to design the panda. Womens brains by stephen jay gould in the prelude to middlemarch, george eliot lamented the unfulfilled lives of talented. It is the second volume culled from his 27year monthly column this view of life in natural history magazine. That is what is at the crux of gould s argument if evolutionnature was an intelligent engineer we might expect pandas to be equipped with opposable thumbs. He was also one of the most influential and widely read authors of popular science of his generation. The pandas thumb argument is entirely philosophical, and isnt even consistent. And to gould, the thumb of the giant panda was the epitome of a funny solution. Part one was an essay that stephen jay gould published in natural history in 1978 called the panda s peculiar thumb. It is plain to see that goulds argument begs the question.
Giant pandas and the distantly related red pandas may have independently evolved an extra digit a false thumb through changes to the. Napoleon, overextended, sealed his doom in the depth of a russian winter. Stephen jay gould s wellknown example of a trait of this type is the panda s thumb. Stephen jay gould, the pandas peculiar thumb 1978 when nature uses a tinkertoy approach, evolutions role becomes more apparent few heroes lower their sights in the prime of their lives. Pandas do in fact have five parallel digits, just like other bears. It is the authors wife wearing a homemade mask with cottonwood marsh in the background. But the panda has a perfectly good builtin wrist bone knife that slices bamboo with amazing ease, as if it were specially designed for that exact purpose. Stephen jay gould is a serious and gifted interpreter of biological theory, of the history of ideas, and of the cultural context of scientific discoverythe pandas thumb is fresh and mindstretching. Panda thumbs its nose at the dysteleological arguments of. Stephen jay gould argues that the thumb of the panda which really consists of uniquely modified wrist bones functions much worse for grasping objects, such as bamboo shoots, than does the true opposable thumb found in humans and therefore gould says it has poor design. But this useful thumb is not really a thumb at all, at least in our sense of the word.
While a divine designer would have given all thumbbearing species whatever the optimal thumb is probably our own, evolution simply adapts. More reflections in natural history stephen jay gould with a touch of humor, geology, evolutionary theory, biology, cartoon characters and even some references to baseball, the pandas thumb definitely makes excellent reading for people with all types of interests. Reflections in natural history stephen jay gould the pandas thumb more reflections in natural history stephen jay gould the pandas thumb more reflections big fish delights millions of players daily with toprated match 3, hopa, time management. The panda s thumb is totally unrelated to our own thumbs. The pandas thumb stephen jay gould essay 723 words. Life in the trees, not bamboo, shaped the pandas thumb. In the panda s thumb, a book of essays, gould explained that the socalled thumb that allows the panda to strip the leaves off bamboo is really part of.
Stephen jay gould argues that the panda s thumb shows evidence of its history in other species because. By stephen jay gould the panda s thumb by stephen jay gould there is grandeur in this view of life, wrote charles darwin in the last line of the origin of species, with its several powers, having been originally breathed into a few forms or into one. The problem for the darwinists is that this actually turns out to be an argument for a designer rather than an argument against one. More reflections in natural history 1980 is a collection of 31 essays by the harvard university paleontologist stephen jay gould. Good theology and bad design or bad theology and good design. The panda thumbs its nose at the dysteleological arguments of the atheist stephen jay gould by john woodmorappe the pandas odd forelimb arrangement has an enlarged wristbone digit commonly called the pandas thumb. An explication of several of the objections offered by david hume to the teleological argument from analogy for the existence of god. Is the pandas thumb a clumsy adaptation that refutes intelligent. Gould claimed that an actual intelligent designer would have made the panda s thumb the same as the human thumb. While a divine designer would have given all thumbbearing species whatever the optimal thumb is probably our own, evolution simply adapts what is already there. Its a classic example of gould s skill at making a provocative argument. We did not wear masks during our 1hour or so walk around walden ponds in boulder, but people were extremely careful to stay 2 or more meters apart.
In the panda s thumb, gould delights and instructs while deepening and. But all this shows is variation, not evolution, possibly occurring in the panda. Alexander wept because he had no new worlds to conquer. This partly explains the extraordinary appeal of the 31 pieces in the panda s thumb. Womens brains is an essay reprinted in stephen jay gould s 1980 book the panda s thumb.
Gould has the ability to astonish and amuse us with his explanation of how the panda s thumb is actually a sort of sixth finger that may have been fashioned by a simple genetic change, perhaps a single mutation affecting the timing and rate of growth. The pandas thumb stephen jay gould the pandas thumb. Stephen jay gould possesses the rare ability to write competently and interestingly about science for intelligent laymen. They also nullify gould s argument that the panda s thumb ostensibly had to evolve in the manner that it did because of its supposed specialized ursine ancestry. Evolutionists have argued that this arrangement is bad design, and so the panda would not have been created but must have evovled. Excerpted from discovering intelligent design, by gary kemper, hallie kemper, and casey luskin. First, your complaint alleges that your lifecode book, in both the 2004 and 2007 versions, was published by ryland press, inc. Stephen jay gould is a serious and gifted interpreter of biological theory, of the history of ideas, and of the cultural context of scientific discoverythe panda s thumb is fresh and mindstretching.
781 343 318 1385 1188 73 773 973 233 1010 1632 149 1479 1194 1439 856 671 1255 1433 444 270 1110 578 413 1214 732 732 835 1194 545 610 323 1229 344 1405 784 727 872 609 954 661 509 1258 513 535 768 1462 827